VIP.Zappos.com - Powered by Service

Johnston & Murphy

View All Brands

Johnston & Murphy Reviews

Tyndall Cap Toe
Tyndall Cap Toe Posted: 10/23/14
Reviewer: from NYC
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

Very attractive shoe. Wide heel. No removable insole unfortunately and not enough room to squeeze my insoles in on top of the glued-in insole. Sole has fine pattern that gives decent traction on carpet and smooth surfaces. Sounds like a stiff expensive board room shoe, but quite comfortable out of the box.

Conard Cap Toe
Conard Cap Toe Posted: 10/23/14
Reviewer: from california
Overall: Rated:4 stars! Comfort: Rated:4 stars! Style: Rated:4 stars!

Great looking shoe, as the other reviewer mentioned, it feels a half size larger than I expected (I have other Johnston & Murphy shoes in a 10 but in this shoe a 10 feels long). the external appearance is great, the only shortcoming in my mind is that only the heel area is lined with leather. The rest of the shoe is lined with fabric. I suppose this is somewhat expected at this price point but it is still a bit disappointing.

Hartley Plain Toe
Hartley Plain Toe Posted: 10/23/14
Reviewer: B K from Brooklyn
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

Just got this shoe - have to say its pretty amazing. I am surprised by how comfortable it is. By the looks of it, you will definitely need a shoe tree. It also feels like it will require some break in but without major pain.

Shuler Bike
Shuler Bike Posted: 10/17/14
Reviewer: Gus from Seattle
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

This is a nicely constructed shoe of quality materials. Sizing in a 14 was very long, a full inch longer overall than my other size 14 shoes. Size 13 was even a bit long. I rarely fit in 13's.

Atchison Cap Toe
Atchison Cap Toe Posted: 10/15/14
Reviewer: George from
Overall: Rated:3 stars! Comfort: Rated:3 stars! Style: Rated:3 stars!

While I know the J&M lost some quality to their name, I still thought they would be ok. I did not mind the rubber sole seeing that they were stitched and not cemented. However, this rubber they used might as well have been wood. They have not worn in, and they are stiffer then a 2x4. Very disappointed. One cannot find a shoe store anymore, and we are stuck with crap on our feet only to be bought online going through a series of returns before we find the right shoe . . . unless you are prepared to spend $$$ and up.

Shuler Bike
Shuler Bike Posted: 10/15/14
Reviewer: from baltimore, md
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

Great buy - comfortable the moment I put them on. Great casual shoe with jeans and walking cobblestone streets was a breeze. Little to no break in time with these. Very happy with my purchase.

Copeland Chukka
Copeland Chukka Posted: 10/14/14
Reviewer: Justin Rinald from
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

I really like the way this shoe looks with jeans and khakis, great style. Comfort is a bit off. Apparently my foot is wider than normal so these are running a bit tight. Nothing I can't deal with, but hopefully they will wear in a little and stretch.

Shuler Bike
Shuler Bike Posted: 10/14/14
Reviewer: Jacob Vargas from Austin, TX
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

I have been shopping for shoes at Zappos for years since I'm size 14 and can't find anything at retail stores. This is my first product review because the moment I put these shoes on, I knew I had to let others know how incredibly comfortable they are. There is virtually no break-in needed. I opted for the wider fit and it was a good call. I met someone else with the same shoes and he shared it was his second pair because of how great they feel. Do yourself a favor and buy these shoes now.

Conard Gore Boot
Conard Gore Boot Posted: 10/13/14
Reviewer: Robert Atkinson from Honolulu
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

Very comfortable, supportive. I spend a lot of time on my feet and will probably add my own arch supports purchased at drug store (Dr. Scholl's, etc).

Melton
Melton Posted: 10/13/14
Reviewer: from
Overall: Rated:1 stars! Comfort: Rated:1 stars! Style: Rated:1 stars!

Single least comfortable shoe I've ever worn. I had them on for a day and that was enough. It was like walking around with wooden boxes on my feet. I've had a long, good history with Johnston & Murphy so they'll get one more chance (just one), but definitely not on these shoes.

Tracey Ankle Strap
Tracey Ankle Strap Posted: 10/10/14
Reviewer: Brooke from Dayton, OH
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

I love these shoes! I wrote a review already for these! I went with the half size up in the grey. They fit perfect & look perfect. Thank you Zappos! You guys are awesome!

Tyndall Cap Toe
Tyndall Cap Toe Posted: 10/9/14
Reviewer: Eduardo Mani from Tinley Park, IL (Chicago)
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

J&M shoes are the best. Extremely comfortable. This is my second pair of J&M.

Tracey Ankle Strap
Tracey Ankle Strap Posted: 10/6/14
Reviewer: Brooke from Dayton, OH
Overall: Rated:4 stars! Comfort: Rated:4 stars! Style: Rated:4 stars!

I love these shoes but they are bit too narrow in the front. It is possible that I may need to go up half a size (to 8, which I never wear) to make them more comfortable. Unfortunately the color that I needed also sold out.

Hartley Plain Toe
Hartley Plain Toe Posted: 10/3/14
Reviewer: Kathy Secor from Saint Charles
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

I purchased these shoes for my husband to wear at our daughter's wedding. He is not easy to please, but found these shoes to be comfortable for the entire day and evening with no break in!

Shuler Bike
Shuler Bike Posted: 10/2/14
Reviewer: B. A. Butler from Houston, TX
Overall: Rated:4 stars! Comfort: Rated:4 stars! Style: Rated:4 stars!

Very comfortable. Very hard to wear out. I have had several pairs now. They will easily last 5 years. Replaced only because the leather got old-looking, but the shoes had many more miles in them. The only problem is that the sheepskin lining has a bad smell after they have been worn. I don't like that part, but I put up with it.

Aragon II
Aragon II Posted: 9/29/14
Reviewer: from Hollywood CA
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

This is a really great shoe but I must have a 10.5 Wide so I've chosen to try and exchange it. If your policies won't allow this size exchange I like the shoe so much that I pay for this one if necessary. it's forming great to my bad feet so I know that this will be my last and greatest exchange. Thank you!

Marcie Ballet
Marcie Ballet Posted: 9/26/14
Reviewer: Karen Anderson from Seattle, Washington
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

The first time I've tried this brand and I was pleasantly surprised. This flat is very comfortable and supportive and is attractive for business wear. It is a tad on the plain (generic) side in appearance but obviously high quality leather and excellent construction.

Lani Zip Bootie
Lani Zip Bootie Posted: 9/25/14
Reviewer: from Iowa
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

I absolutely LOVE these shoes. I was in need of a new boot for winter to wear to work and this exceeds my expectations. I was concerned about the price but figured with Zappos free shipping I could send it back if it didn't work out. I'm so glad I ordered them. I still have sticker shock (most expensive shoe I've ever purchased) but I couldn't imagine a boot that I'd love more. I will be wearing them every day! I just hope they hold up since they are so expensive. I think they will because they seem to be very well constructed with great quality material. I highly recommend these! They are also very comfortable.

Weekender Case
Weekender Case Posted: 9/23/14
Reviewer: Kate from Texas
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

This card case is just the right size for your cards, license, and a few bills. My husband and my teen both prefer this style to the folding, bulkier kind. The price is attractive, too.

Cardell Saddle
Cardell Saddle Posted: 9/22/14
Reviewer: from Los Angeles, CA, USA
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

I tried these while hunting for a nice pair of dress shoes for special events. They are INCREDIBLY comfortable right out of the box. The sheepskin lining inside is very soft and I could tell that they would be comfortable being worn over a long day. They are also waterproof, which also makes them a bit warmer, too. Bottom line, they didn't fit my needs (I live in a warm, dry climate and was looking for shoe for special occasions). These are fantastically comfortable shoes that look great and will keep your feet dry and warm in the elements and keep your feet comfortable over a long work day. Those aren't my needs, but for someone who wears business attire a lot and commutes in elements, these are perfect. They look great, too.

Shawna Chelsea Boot
Shawna Chelsea Boot Posted: 9/22/14
Reviewer: Katherine from Brooklyn, NY
Overall: Rated:5 stars! Comfort: Rated:5 stars! Style: Rated:5 stars!

This is a beautiful, stylish bootie, very soft leather with a supportive sole. Unfortunately, they're going back. I wear a size 8 but I always buy an 8 1/2 in boots so that I can wear my orthotics in them. I ordered these in brown and black in an 8 1/2. They are too short, however, even without the orthotics. My toes are right up against the toe box, really uncomfortable. Very disappointed. I've ordered a 9 in brown but the black is sold out, which is what I really needed. Please, someone, return your size 9s in black so Zappos can send them to me!

Free Shipping Both Ways · 24/7 Customer Service · 365 Day Return Policy

Zappos Family Core Value:

10. Be Humble